Misleading information

Hi Mario, own all your stuff. Love what you’re doing.

I purchased MNodes with expectation that all future updates were included with the early supporters price.

“MNodes costs 79€. It never goes on sale and updates are free. The project keeps growing, so I’m thinking about raising the price.

Translation: the best time to buy MNodes is now”

The the last email I received contained the following… (regarding plugin export)

“It will probably be a separate version, maybe with a different price (if you already own MNodes, you’ll just be able to upgrade if you want). A couple of things left to close, but it’s on its way.”

Ummm - this diverges from your original “promise” to your early adopters.

Please clarify this Mario.

Hi emdebee,

As a moderator i would like to say welcome to the forum. Now i personally can’t pick up on your question since i can’t be aware of any personal communication between you and Mario about this. At least i am totally unaware of such a promise while i bought MNode month’s ago.

So personally to clarify the situation, as i can’t find anything on discord, from e-mails or on this forum where it was granted as a free update or included at all with MNode while this could easily be me, missing out on a message anywhere.

Could you point out the communication, is there any statement made that was perceived like that?

I think this helps out solving the issue. Now as a i said, i can’t pick up the question then only want to address your concerns and some proof might help out.

If you want to keep communication about it privately, i completely understand and i would suggest then to get in contact with Mario directly without open communication, been read by everyone.

Just in case, if so required mario@marionietoworld.com

Hope you get your situation solved in any way so that its clarified.

It’s all in the last email Mario sent out today…

“Hey, Mario here.

Today I’m trying a different kind of email… the best copywriters say this style is more interesting for the reader. Or something like that.

If it feels forced, I get it. You have to try things. (And in case you’re wondering… of course I run it through AI afterwards so it fixes my text…)

Let’s get to it.

New here? I want to tell you about some changes to my new project (well, not so new anymore): MNodes. A plugin for building your own plugins without code, or for making music with other people’s projects. And it comes loaded with ready-made instruments and effects…

MNodes keeps getting better, partly thanks to you. Fixes everywhere and new nodes: Groove (a Euclidean sequencer), Motif (melodies built from tonal distances) and Chord Palette (fast, flexible chord progressions), and a few more…

And since everything is nodes and connections, you twist the data any way you want and build your own plugins.

Now the good part.

People keep asking me if MNodes will export VST3.

I have a version running at home.

You build your project, add your name and your brand, hit one button and boom: a closed VST3, ready to distribute.

Want to sell it? Sell it. Through your own channels, no fees. Not a cent for me.

(NOTE: exports run on the JUCE framework, so distributing them needs your own JUCE licence. Free up to a certain level of sales. Full details at launch.)

It will probably be a separate version, maybe with a different price (if you already own MNodes, you’ll just be able to upgrade if you want). A couple of things left to close, but it’s on its way.

Meanwhile, business as usual: more nodes, better workflow, bugs out, MNodes running smoother. Day in, day out.

If MNodes can be better today, why wait until tomorrow to give it to you? That’s why I release a new version every few days.

One last thing.

MNodes costs 79€. It never goes on sale and updates are free. The project keeps growing, so I’m thinking about raising the price.

Translation: the best time to buy MNodes is now.

If you think it’s for you, that is.

https://marionietoworld.com/mnodes/

Questions or requests, drop by the forum. I read them all.
https://forum.marionietoworld.com/

Oh, by the way: there are other tools you might like. All of them here:
https://marionietoworld.com/

Mario”

Does not really divert… I understood the pledge to cover the creation of nodes within a framework that allowed sharing via the use of mnodes.

Allowing sharing/selling via the creation of an actual standalone vst goes way way beyond that, so charging an additional upgrade fee seems entirely reasonable. You are talking about the ability to create potentially commercial products.

Another factor to consider is the already entirely reasonable cost of mnodes itself.

Just my 2 cents worth.

Okay, i think it’s the perception what’s an update and what is an upgrade. and how this related to each other. For me it’s like having any software and upgrade it with an extension or new ability to do something else than the main product is about.

But i think also, Mnode keeps being a node editor and there might be just about a new tool that exports it to a VST3.

Well, best for me not to get involved of course how to explain this from my perception. I am natively not english speaking and which each language barrier there is that perceiving of expressions. And i can easily set a trap for myself :slight_smile:

So at best, i would have to leave the final answer to Mario.

I’m definitely not having a go here - just pointing out something that ought to be declared - it’s murky at best currently. I will continue supporting Mario - love his “stuff” but when it goes from 79euro for all upgrades, forever - to plugin export being a paid upgrade seems odd to me. I’d consider that would be an update… anyways :person_shrugging:

i knew what i bought when i did nowhere was the promise of vst3 export so to me this is an add on you can choose to get

and i can understand some why’s also because using the juice framework comes with its own caviats and rules you have to follow not because of mario but because of juice and thus falls outside the range of mnodes itself

and honnestly 79 is a steal for what you get he could have asked 279 imo

Hey emdebee, you are right that when not every nuance is spelled out in every
message, confusion can happen, so from now on I will try to be even clearer in
how I communicate. Let me be precise here.

The promise you bought into does not change: MNodes costs 79 EUR (today), it
never goes on sale, and every update to MNodes is free. To be extra clear, and
I have mentioned this in other emails and in some streams: this covers the
current MNodes, version 1. And honestly, I do not even know when a version 2
might arrive. It could be years from now. It might never happen. It might even
end up being free. Since I do not have it clear myself, I would rather repeat
it here than leave room for surprises later.

The VST3 export is a different thing: a separate edition (probably called
MNodes Export), not an update to MNodes. If you own MNodes and want it, you
will pay the difference, not the full price again. And if you never need to
ship standalone VST3s, you lose nothing: the version you own keeps growing for
free, and it stays cheaper precisely because not everyone needs exporting.

There were other ways to do this: charging a fee on every plugin you sell, or
watermarking the exports with MNodes branding. I did not want that. I want you
to be able to create a completely closed VST3, under your own name, that you
can sell wherever you want with no fees to me and nothing owed to me. (As
mentioned in the email, exported plugins are built on the JUCE framework, so
selling them requires your own JUCE licence, which is free for most people.
That part is not mine, but I will always be upfront about it.) It is the same
spirit as Max/RNBO: the tool is paid, and what you make with it is yours,
royalty free. It also means the only place this work can be paid for is the
edition itself.

My commitment stays the same: whoever buys today gets the best price there
will ever be. I would rather give the advantage to the people who are already
here than to the ones who arrive later.

I will try to be more precise in my communications.

I appreciate the detailed clarification…

Cheers,

Marcus